Home
Do you own this product?
Write an online review and share your thoughts!
Do you own this product? ( Keen Sienna Mary Jane )
Write an online review and share your thoughts with other Zappos.com customers!
86% of Fit Survey respondents said this shoe "Felt true to size"
93% of Fit Survey respondents said this shoe "Felt true to width"
87% of Fit Survey respondents said this shoe had "Moderate arch support"
Customer Rating/Review
Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Number of reviews: 189
Average customer ratings:
Overall:
Comfort: Look:
2009-11-13 15:25:13 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous from Georgia
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
These are some great shoes! I walked all over San Francisco in these shoes, and they were so comfortable. I wear them with and without socks, and they are very versatile. They are too cute! I have no complaints about this shoe. I didn't even have to "break" them in! They were comfortable from the beginning!
2009-11-03 13:09:34 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Theresa from Salin
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
These are the cutest, comfortable shoes! I have really bad feet and I wore them all day and didn't have any problems. Love the elastic on the top to help keep the shoe on. You cannot go wrong with these.
2009-11-02 06:23:42 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Sarah M from Washington DC
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
I bought these shoes in black and then bought them again in sienna. I usually wear a 8.5. But with these the 9 works really well. They are really comfortable and cute. I wear them with and w/out socks and they are warm w/out.\r\n\r\n
2009-10-27 11:58:26 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Leise G from Washington, DC
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
My sister wore these shoes when she came to visit me. After trying them on I had to have them (even though she has larger feet than me)! These shoes are very comfy and go well with jeans and skirts. I've had problems with Keen sizing before, but having tried my sister's shoes I knew I would need a 7 instead of my regular 6.5. I wear these both with and without socks.
2009-10-17 05:41:05 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
Pretty cute shoe that mostly fit comfortably right out of the box. I had some pressure at the top of my foot by my big toe, but I have high arches so it’s really my foot that's the issue, not the shoe. At any rate, the leather stretched and it fits fine now. I don't necessarily love the look of the rubber toe but they are Keens and that's the aesthetic. The Port Royale color is very nice and I get lots of compliments. Unfortunately they are not big enough to accommodate my orthotic but that's okay, I hate wearing it anyway!
2009-10-16 07:33:49 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
Really comfortable, was able to wear it right out the box without breaking them in. Being waterproof is also really convenient.
2009-10-14 09:09:01 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Barbara P from California
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
This is my third purchase of Keen shoes, twice in this design. They are exceptionally well made, long-lasting and attractive. What more can a buyer want? By the way, choose a half size down even if you will wear the shoes with socks. Thanks Zappos for great customer service.
2009-10-08 18:04:13 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous from Massachusetts
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
Love this shoe, bought it for traveling in Europe, and the look was great with everything. Its a comfy shoe, but no support, so after a lot of walking around my feet were hurting.
2009-09-30 18:11:22 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Leslie P from Dallas Texas
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
These are actually more comfortable than I thought they would be. I can also put my arch supports in them. I wish they came in dark brown. I definitely get another pair!
2009-09-30 03:44:47 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous from Hawaii
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
First off, I have to say that I absolutely love the style of Keen shoes. They have this chunky, outdoorsy, yet modern charm to them, which I adore. Unfortunately, I have had a consistent problem with defective merchandise. The two Keen shoes I ordered, the Sienna Mary Jane and the Keen Waimea H2, both had defects so I had to return them. The Waimea H2's strap was unraveling and the Sienna Mary Janes had stitched coming apart. The replacement Waimea H2 sandals were fine and now I am waiting on the replacement Sienna Mary Janes. I hope those arrive in perfect working order. I do not know if it is some coincidence or fluke that the first two Keen shoes I have ever ordered were made badly, or if this is a sign of generally bad workmanship. I hope it is just a fluke because these shoes are so cute and comfortable. That said, I give Zappos five stars for having amazing customer service!
Other shoes recommended by reviewer: Merrell
2009-09-27 07:50:48 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous from Chicago IL
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
I tried the 10.5 and 10 in these and went with the 10.5 (although I have a 10 in the similar style Keen Barcelona). These are extremely comfortable right out of the box without socks, no breaking-in period! And they are absolutely adorable; the perfect tennis shoe comfort that you can still wear with a skirt and not look like you are a gym-shoe wearing commuter. I was a little worried about the tan sole contrasting obnoxiously with body of the shoe (forest night), but the two are a bit closer in value (i.e. light/dark) than in the photo. Love them.
Other shoes recommended by reviewer: earth shoe, dansko, camper
2009-09-26 07:58:04 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Marti K from Sonoma County, CA
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
These are great shoes. I now have them in two colors. I would get every color but that might look odd. Comfortable as soon as you put them on. Not so padded as other Keens, so not for long walks. But actually more comfortable.
2009-09-24 19:17:58 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Susan M from Oregon
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
Loved these Keens. Lots of room in the toe. I have skinny feet, so the elastic across the top helps. Very comfy for walking, right from the start; no breaking in period. I usually order Keens 1/2 a size up, but these were absolutely true to size.
Other shoes recommended by reviewer: Born
2009-09-24 09:56:27 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous from napa, ca
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
Zappos service is extremely good. Guess I was hoping that the Mary Janes would be like walking on air; not quite, but they are fine. I was apprehensive about buying shoes without trying them on first; the only way I was convinced was the return shipping policy. I am keeping the shoes, like the style.
Other shoes recommended by reviewer: arche and aerosole
2009-09-19 16:29:59 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Susan M from Virginia
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
As usual, I received free next day shipping! I tried the 6.5 first and had to order the 7.0. Most people had recommended a half-size up with Keen. I have narrow heels and ankles and had to insert heel cushions. I also replaced the inserts with something a little more cushiony. This may only be due to a lingering foot/ankle injury. I was able maneuver through airports from Virginia to Europe and back in these shoes with no blisters. They are very cute and the coffee liquer color is very versatile. I will definitely try more Keens!
Other shoes recommended by reviewer: Teva
2009-09-16 09:25:13 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous from Seattle WA
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
These are the most comfortable shoes I've ever worn! I got them in rust and brown, and strangely, the rust are super, super comfortable, and the brown have a tight spot on top and chafed my heel a wee bit, but I'm sure they'll break in. The rust pair did not need to be broken in. They feel very lightweight, and the elastic band on top keeps the shoe from slipping at all. LOVE!
2009-09-15 19:56:31 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Kristi from Victor, ID
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
The shoes are perfect for what I needed; dressy enough to wear with a skirt to work, yet casual and comfortable. They are not appropriate for walking any significant distance as they have no arch support, but are comfortable enough to wear all day. However, beware: I have been wearing them without socks and they stink! I have never had stinky feet before, but these shoes get ripe!
2009-09-14 08:09:22 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Beth L from Birmingham, AL
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
I love these shoes! Comfortable from the moment I first put them on. I have "difficult" feet, with a bunion on the left foot, but these have not hurt at all. Great for "running around", grocery shopping, etc., day to day wear. Sometimes, on a longer walk, they do seem like they could use more padding on the bottom. So, if you do a lot of walking, you might like to add an insert, but I love them. First got the coffee color, then the black and green!
Other shoes recommended by reviewer: Terrasoles, Tsubo
2009-09-10 14:59:25 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous from Vermont
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
I love these shoes. They are comfy and look great on. The only problem is there is no ventilation, so because they are made to not wear socks. Your feet get really smelly!
Other shoes recommended by reviewer: merrel
2009-09-09 08:53:24 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Liz Filippone from San Francisco, CA
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
My feet were so happy once I put them in these shoes! I've been trying to buy shoes that give lots of space for my feet and toes, especially and these did the trick. Also, they go with a lot of outfits. I didn't even get blisters when I wore them the first time. Overall, great comfort and support, even for my arches. I need something that gives my arches a lift.
2009-09-03 06:00:05 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous from Maryland
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
I love these shoes. They are the most comfortable shoes ever. The only problem is that they don't have any arch support so I added some.
Other shoes recommended by reviewer: Rieker
2009-08-05 09:50:48 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous from Los Angeles
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
I really like the look and feel of these shoes. I have several Keen products and this is sleeker and more feminine than the others. I wear a 9.5 or 10. I bought the 10 and probably should have gone with the 9.5, since I wear these without socks. Really great work shoe.
2009-07-29 10:25:15 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous from Memphis, TN
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
I love these shoes so much. I have extremely long skinny feet and have much difficulty finding shoes that stay on, are comfortable, and cute. These do all that and more. They're adorable, they match everything, and feel so good on. I got them in black, coffee, and forest green. All three colors match everything. And I love Zappos for being my favorite place to buy shoes online. I don't trust any other site as much as Zappos. If you want good service, buy from Zappos. If you want comfortable, cute shoes, buy these.
2009-07-23 07:25:15 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Jessica F from Texas
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
AWESOME shoes! I bought these shoes (2 pair-the sandy and violet) before my 2.5 week trip to Europe. I wore the sandy ones to work a day before my trip and i was AMAZED at how comfy they are (feel like butter) and i had NO sore spots or blisters on my feet. I brought both pairs with me to Europe and wore them for hours walking and had NO problems. These are WONDERFUL walking shoes and they look cute with capris, pants, and shorts. LOVE LOVE LOVE these shoes!
2009-07-18 15:54:26 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Andrew Knauff from Long Island, New York
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:
I bought these shoes for my girlfriend without really knowing much about them. However, they are Keens, and everyone I know that has Keens think they are extremely comfortable. Based on that, I went ahead and got them. The size ran true to fit (she wears a womans 7 and fit her perfectly) and she thinks they are super comfy. The variety of colors offered as well is a plus, as normally many styles of Keens just come in some shade of brown or black.
Top
Write an online review and share your thoughts with other Zappos.com customers!
86% of Fit Survey respondents said this shoe "Felt true to size"
93% of Fit Survey respondents said this shoe "Felt true to width"
87% of Fit Survey respondents said this shoe had "Moderate arch support"
Customer Rating/Review
Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Number of reviews: 189
Average customer ratings:
Overall:
Comfort: Look: 2009-11-13 15:25:13 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous from Georgia
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:These are some great shoes! I walked all over San Francisco in these shoes, and they were so comfortable. I wear them with and without socks, and they are very versatile. They are too cute! I have no complaints about this shoe. I didn't even have to "break" them in! They were comfortable from the beginning!
2009-11-03 13:09:34 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Theresa from Salin
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:These are the cutest, comfortable shoes! I have really bad feet and I wore them all day and didn't have any problems. Love the elastic on the top to help keep the shoe on. You cannot go wrong with these.
2009-11-02 06:23:42 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Sarah M from Washington DC
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:I bought these shoes in black and then bought them again in sienna. I usually wear a 8.5. But with these the 9 works really well. They are really comfortable and cute. I wear them with and w/out socks and they are warm w/out.\r\n\r\n
2009-10-27 11:58:26 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Leise G from Washington, DC
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:My sister wore these shoes when she came to visit me. After trying them on I had to have them (even though she has larger feet than me)! These shoes are very comfy and go well with jeans and skirts. I've had problems with Keen sizing before, but having tried my sister's shoes I knew I would need a 7 instead of my regular 6.5. I wear these both with and without socks.
2009-10-17 05:41:05 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:Pretty cute shoe that mostly fit comfortably right out of the box. I had some pressure at the top of my foot by my big toe, but I have high arches so it’s really my foot that's the issue, not the shoe. At any rate, the leather stretched and it fits fine now. I don't necessarily love the look of the rubber toe but they are Keens and that's the aesthetic. The Port Royale color is very nice and I get lots of compliments. Unfortunately they are not big enough to accommodate my orthotic but that's okay, I hate wearing it anyway!
2009-10-16 07:33:49 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:Really comfortable, was able to wear it right out the box without breaking them in. Being waterproof is also really convenient.
2009-10-14 09:09:01 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Barbara P from California
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:This is my third purchase of Keen shoes, twice in this design. They are exceptionally well made, long-lasting and attractive. What more can a buyer want? By the way, choose a half size down even if you will wear the shoes with socks. Thanks Zappos for great customer service.
2009-10-08 18:04:13 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous from Massachusetts
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:Love this shoe, bought it for traveling in Europe, and the look was great with everything. Its a comfy shoe, but no support, so after a lot of walking around my feet were hurting.
2009-09-30 18:11:22 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Leslie P from Dallas Texas
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:These are actually more comfortable than I thought they would be. I can also put my arch supports in them. I wish they came in dark brown. I definitely get another pair!
2009-09-30 03:44:47 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous from Hawaii
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:First off, I have to say that I absolutely love the style of Keen shoes. They have this chunky, outdoorsy, yet modern charm to them, which I adore. Unfortunately, I have had a consistent problem with defective merchandise. The two Keen shoes I ordered, the Sienna Mary Jane and the Keen Waimea H2, both had defects so I had to return them. The Waimea H2's strap was unraveling and the Sienna Mary Janes had stitched coming apart. The replacement Waimea H2 sandals were fine and now I am waiting on the replacement Sienna Mary Janes. I hope those arrive in perfect working order. I do not know if it is some coincidence or fluke that the first two Keen shoes I have ever ordered were made badly, or if this is a sign of generally bad workmanship. I hope it is just a fluke because these shoes are so cute and comfortable. That said, I give Zappos five stars for having amazing customer service!
Other shoes recommended by reviewer: Merrell
2009-09-27 07:50:48 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous from Chicago IL
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:I tried the 10.5 and 10 in these and went with the 10.5 (although I have a 10 in the similar style Keen Barcelona). These are extremely comfortable right out of the box without socks, no breaking-in period! And they are absolutely adorable; the perfect tennis shoe comfort that you can still wear with a skirt and not look like you are a gym-shoe wearing commuter. I was a little worried about the tan sole contrasting obnoxiously with body of the shoe (forest night), but the two are a bit closer in value (i.e. light/dark) than in the photo. Love them.
Other shoes recommended by reviewer: earth shoe, dansko, camper
2009-09-26 07:58:04 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Marti K from Sonoma County, CA
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:These are great shoes. I now have them in two colors. I would get every color but that might look odd. Comfortable as soon as you put them on. Not so padded as other Keens, so not for long walks. But actually more comfortable.
2009-09-24 19:17:58 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Susan M from Oregon
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:Loved these Keens. Lots of room in the toe. I have skinny feet, so the elastic across the top helps. Very comfy for walking, right from the start; no breaking in period. I usually order Keens 1/2 a size up, but these were absolutely true to size.
Other shoes recommended by reviewer: Born
2009-09-24 09:56:27 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous from napa, ca
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:Zappos service is extremely good. Guess I was hoping that the Mary Janes would be like walking on air; not quite, but they are fine. I was apprehensive about buying shoes without trying them on first; the only way I was convinced was the return shipping policy. I am keeping the shoes, like the style.
Other shoes recommended by reviewer: arche and aerosole
2009-09-19 16:29:59 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Susan M from Virginia
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:As usual, I received free next day shipping! I tried the 6.5 first and had to order the 7.0. Most people had recommended a half-size up with Keen. I have narrow heels and ankles and had to insert heel cushions. I also replaced the inserts with something a little more cushiony. This may only be due to a lingering foot/ankle injury. I was able maneuver through airports from Virginia to Europe and back in these shoes with no blisters. They are very cute and the coffee liquer color is very versatile. I will definitely try more Keens!
Other shoes recommended by reviewer: Teva
2009-09-16 09:25:13 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous from Seattle WA
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:These are the most comfortable shoes I've ever worn! I got them in rust and brown, and strangely, the rust are super, super comfortable, and the brown have a tight spot on top and chafed my heel a wee bit, but I'm sure they'll break in. The rust pair did not need to be broken in. They feel very lightweight, and the elastic band on top keeps the shoe from slipping at all. LOVE!
2009-09-15 19:56:31 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Kristi from Victor, ID
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:The shoes are perfect for what I needed; dressy enough to wear with a skirt to work, yet casual and comfortable. They are not appropriate for walking any significant distance as they have no arch support, but are comfortable enough to wear all day. However, beware: I have been wearing them without socks and they stink! I have never had stinky feet before, but these shoes get ripe!
2009-09-14 08:09:22 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Beth L from Birmingham, AL
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:I love these shoes! Comfortable from the moment I first put them on. I have "difficult" feet, with a bunion on the left foot, but these have not hurt at all. Great for "running around", grocery shopping, etc., day to day wear. Sometimes, on a longer walk, they do seem like they could use more padding on the bottom. So, if you do a lot of walking, you might like to add an insert, but I love them. First got the coffee color, then the black and green!
Other shoes recommended by reviewer: Terrasoles, Tsubo
2009-09-10 14:59:25 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous from Vermont
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:I love these shoes. They are comfy and look great on. The only problem is there is no ventilation, so because they are made to not wear socks. Your feet get really smelly!
Other shoes recommended by reviewer: merrel
2009-09-09 08:53:24 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Liz Filippone from San Francisco, CA
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:My feet were so happy once I put them in these shoes! I've been trying to buy shoes that give lots of space for my feet and toes, especially and these did the trick. Also, they go with a lot of outfits. I didn't even get blisters when I wore them the first time. Overall, great comfort and support, even for my arches. I need something that gives my arches a lift.
2009-09-03 06:00:05 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous from Maryland
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:I love these shoes. They are the most comfortable shoes ever. The only problem is that they don't have any arch support so I added some.
Other shoes recommended by reviewer: Rieker
2009-08-05 09:50:48 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous from Los Angeles
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:I really like the look and feel of these shoes. I have several Keen products and this is sleeker and more feminine than the others. I wear a 9.5 or 10. I bought the 10 and probably should have gone with the 9.5, since I wear these without socks. Really great work shoe.
2009-07-29 10:25:15 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Anonymous from Memphis, TN
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:I love these shoes so much. I have extremely long skinny feet and have much difficulty finding shoes that stay on, are comfortable, and cute. These do all that and more. They're adorable, they match everything, and feel so good on. I got them in black, coffee, and forest green. All three colors match everything. And I love Zappos for being my favorite place to buy shoes online. I don't trust any other site as much as Zappos. If you want good service, buy from Zappos. If you want comfortable, cute shoes, buy these.
2009-07-23 07:25:15 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Jessica F from Texas
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:AWESOME shoes! I bought these shoes (2 pair-the sandy and violet) before my 2.5 week trip to Europe. I wore the sandy ones to work a day before my trip and i was AMAZED at how comfy they are (feel like butter) and i had NO sore spots or blisters on my feet. I brought both pairs with me to Europe and wore them for hours walking and had NO problems. These are WONDERFUL walking shoes and they look cute with capris, pants, and shorts. LOVE LOVE LOVE these shoes!
2009-07-18 15:54:26 Keen Sienna Mary Jane
Reviewer: Andrew Knauff from Long Island, New York
Overall:
Comfort:
Look:I bought these shoes for my girlfriend without really knowing much about them. However, they are Keens, and everyone I know that has Keens think they are extremely comfortable. Based on that, I went ahead and got them. The size ran true to fit (she wears a womans 7 and fit her perfectly) and she thinks they are super comfy. The variety of colors offered as well is a plus, as normally many styles of Keens just come in some shade of brown or black.
| Next 25 Reviews >> |
Check the boxes and enter your e-mail address below and we'll let you know of:
